When I first approached this puzzle, I had no idea where to start. The only strategy I could think of was to list possible combinations of weights and check which amounts they could measure. What I found especially interesting was how a two-pan balance works. Although each weight has a fixed mass, it can play three different roles: adding to the amount being measured, subtracting from it, or not being used at all. This reminded me of binary, although I later understood that the two-pan version connects to balanced ternary because each weight has three possible states instead of two.
Listing combinations did not lead me to an answer at first, so I tried using algebra to work out the relationships. The calculations felt frustrating while I was still trying to understand how the puzzle worked. However, once the relationships became clear, algebra made the process much quicker. This made me realize that the hardest part of solving a problem is sometimes getting from “0 to 0.1”—finding that first small insight. After that, moving from “0.1 to 1” can feel much smoother.
As a teacher, this makes me wonder how I can help students enjoy that uncertain beginning, when they do not yet know what to do. How can I design classroom activities and assessments that value their attempts, observations, and changes in approach, even before they reach an answer? I would like students to feel that exploring an idea is worthwhile, even when it does not immediately work. I do not yet have a clear idea of what this would look like in my classroom, but I hope that, through this course and more teaching experience, I will gradually learn how to support students through those first small steps.
You approached this problem through algebra rather than trial and error, which offers a different way of thinking about the puzzle. I wonder how you might introduce this approach to students who are not yet comfortable working with several variables.
回复删除Helen, please add an **EDIT with your reflections on working on this problem for full marks!
回复删除